.png)
Romans 5 in the argument of Limited Atonement & Universal Objective Justification
[This content has been adapted from Noah Eskew's book, Loving the World to Death: Scripture's Story of a God Who Died for Every Sinner]
Few books in the Bible carry the theological weight of Paul’s letter to the Romans. It’s often called the crown jewel of the New Testament—and for good reason. While many gravitate toward Romans 8–9, Romans 5 contains one of the most sweeping and breathtaking claims in all of Scripture:
“As one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men” (Romans 5:18).
That’s a massive statement. And if we let Paul speak on his own terms, it reshapes how we understand the cross, justification, and the scope of Christ’s work.
The Problem: Sin for All
Paul builds his argument from a universal reality: “All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). No exceptions. No loopholes. God’s Law silences every mouth (Romans 3:19). Humanity stands guilty. But Paul doesn’t stop there...
The Shock: Justification for All
The very next line is just as sweeping: “…and are justified by His grace as a gift” (Romans 3:24). Notice the parallel: All have sinned → all are justified. Paul is saying that something objective happened at the cross. Jesus didn’t merely make salvation possible—He accomplished something real, something universal. Christ was “delivered up for our trespasses and raised for our justification” (Romans 4:25).
He died “once for all” (Romans 6:10) – one time for all people. God was “reconciling the world to Himself” (2 Corinthians 5:19). At the cross, God dealt with sin completely. The debt was paid. The verdict was issued.
What This Means: Universal Objective Justification
Romans 5 brings it into focus:
One man (Adam) → sin and condemnation for all
One Man (Christ) → righteousness and justification for all
Paul isn’t being poetic—he’s being precise. Just as Adam’s fall affected everyone, Christ’s work reaches just as far… and even further. This is often called universal objective justification: Christ’s death and resurrection accomplished justification for the whole world. That does not mean everyone is automatically saved.
Not Universalism: Why Faith Still Matters
Paul is clear: “Since we have been justified by faith…” (Romans 5:1). Justification must be “received by faith” (Romans 3:24).
Think of it like this: The check has been written, the pardon has been signed, and the prison doors are open...But the gift must be received. Now, faith doesn’t cause justification—it receives what Christ already accomplished.
Why This Matters for the Gospel
If Christ only died for some, the gospel becomes uncertain: Did He die for me? Am I included? But if Christ died for all, the message becomes bold and universal: Your sins are forgiven. The debt is paid. The door is open. That’s why Jesus sends His disciples to preach the gospel “to every creature” (Mark 16:15). There are no exclusions.
Answering Objections: “Double Jeopardy” and "Not all, but 'Many'"
Some argue: “If Christ paid for all sins, how can anyone still be condemned?” But Scripture holds two truths together without tension: Christ died for all, but not all are saved.
Jesus Himself gets rid of the problem of double jeopardy in Matthew 18:32-35, when a servant is forgiven, yet later judged because he, in effect, rejects that mercy by living if his debt was not forgiven. The issue isn’t whether the debt was paid—it’s whether it was received.
And, yes, it's true that at one point in Romans 5, Paul switches from all to many, but don't mistake that as a limitation...In context, all people are in view for Paul, and he uses the word "many" to mean "all" just as the prophet Daniel does: “Many who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake…” (Daniel 12:2).
The Unforgivable Sin
This is why we can say that the unforgivable sin is to deny the Spirit's work of convicting you of sin and convincing you of Christ. Rejecting what Jesus did for you, which is being attested to by the Spirit is a sin that, by default, cannot be forgiven. "Whoever believes in the Son of God has the testimony in himself. Whoever does not believe God has made him a liar, because he has not believed in the testimony that God has borne concerning his Son" (1 John 5:10).
Adam vs. Christ: The Greater Reality
Paul’s comparison is intentional: One sin wrecked the world, Christ’s righteousness overwhelms it. Grace doesn’t merely cancel sin—it surpasses it. “The free gift following many trespasses brought justification” (Romans 5:16). In other words: Millions of sins cannot outmatch one act of Christ.
Quotes on Universal Objective Justification
In an article on 1517's website, Chad Bird explains: “For whom did Christ die? Everyone. Everyone from Adam to the last person who will be born before Christ returns…we often call this ‘objective justification,’ that is, the death and resurrection of Christ have objectively taken care of everyone's justification. All have been died for. God has reconciled all things to himself (Col. 1:20). Atonement for all has been done for all, *whether they believe it or not.* …Faith is the hand that receives it”
Author of "Cross or Glory?" and theologian Steven Hein writes: “There is a universal, finished aspect of justification…In Christ's vicarious atonement, God reconciled the whole world of sinners to Himself, not counting their trespasses against them. (2 Cor. 5:19, Rom. 5:6-18, Col. 2:13-14). He has declared all sinners to be innocent and righteous, forgiven for the sake of Christ's all-sufficient death for the penalty of sin. God has acquired for the whole world the status of sainthood, perfect righteousness, and acceptability in Christ's saving death and resurrection. This declaration of forgiveness and reconciliation is presented by Paul…as existing in the present as a result of God’s saving work in Christ in the past…God has already reconciled Himself to a world of sinners, and this reconciliation exists as a universal objective reality in Christ. Anyone and everyone, regardless of how wretched they may think they are, may look to the cross of Christ and know that they have the full forgiveness of their sins and God's complete favor now and forever. It cannot be stressed enough that the Scriptures reveal…a righteousness of Christ that is universal and sufficient for all sinners. God's saving work and gifts in Christ exist for the whole world. He so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son (John 3:16)…Any conception of a limited atonement-contending that Jesus only died for some sinners-renders an uncertain Gospel message for everyone. A limited view of the atonement of Christ removes confidence in the forgiveness of sins not simply for some, but for every individual sinner. Such a view declares that only some are justified and turns every gospel word into a provisional message: God may have forgiven your sins because He may have sent Jesus to die for your sins, because He may have chosen you to be one of His elect. Any conception of the Gospel that proclaims a limited atonement turns the saving work and gifts of Christ into an uncertainty for any particular sinner.”
“Through His Cross, He graciously bestowed righteousness on us all,” (John Chrysostom).
“One has sinned (Adam), One is righteous (Christ), and many are made righteous. There is no difference between ‘many’ and ‘all.’ The righteousness of Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, our Lord and Savior, is so great that it could justify innumerable worlds. ‘He shall justify many,’ says he, that is to say, all. It should, therefore, be understood of all, because He offers His righteousness to all, and all who believe in Christ obtain it” (Martin Luther, commentary on Isaiah 53:11).
“He makes this favor common to all, because it is propounded to all, and not because it is in reality extended to all; for though Christ suffered for the sins of the whole world, and is offered indiscriminately to all, yet all do not receive Him,” (John Calvin).
“The peace which had been lost in Adam was restored again between God and men” (Andreas Nohrberg).
“Laying His anger aside, a change occurred in the heart of God, who at that time already had in His heart forgiven the sins of the whole world, and at that time we were objectively declared free from sin” (Francis Pieper).
“As all men are involved in the consequences of Adam’s sin, so all may be involved in the results of Christ’s righteousness. The doctrine of universal redemption is here clearly taught, for Christ’s obedience is the cause of the justification of all men who accept it,” (Albert Barnes).
“The one act of righteousness in Christ offers life to all, just as the fall of Adam brought death to all. However, this does not mean that all are saved automatically; rather, Christ's atoning work is available to all, but each person must personally receive the forgiveness Christ offers by faith…Jesus, when He was raised from the dead, was absolved for all sin, but since it was not for Himself but for all people that Christ died, who was it really that was set free, who was it really that was absolved when Jesus rose from the dead? It was all people! Just as all Israel triumphed when David defeated Goliath, so all humanity triumphed when Jesus defeated sin, death and Hell. ‘Then as one man’s trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one man’s act of righteousness leads to acquittal and life for all men.’ Just as Christ’s condemnation was the condemnation of all mankind, Christ’s death the death of all mankind, Christ’s payment the payment for all mankind, even so Christ’s life is now the life of all mankind, His acquittal the acquittal of all mankind, His justification the justification of all mankind, His absolution the absolution of all mankind” (C.F.W. Walther).
“The one act of righteousness by Christ has the power to undo what Adam’s disobedience brought about for all people, not just a few, but all of humanity,” (Karl Barth).
“The victory of Christ is much greater than the defeat in Adam, in terms of the number of persons affected,” (Donald Grey Barnhouse).
A Simple Picture
Imagine you’re dying in a hospital. A cure is given freely—already prepared, already effective. But you tear out the IV and refuse it. You don’t die because there was no cure. You die because you rejected it. That’s how Scripture speaks about salvation.
The Bottom Line
Romans 5 teaches something stunning: Adam’s sin affected all. And Christ’s work affects all too. One death truly means life for all. So if Christ died for all…then He died for you. Not maybe. Not potentially. Actually.
Comments